Theatre Aezir’s The Shark is Broken Hooks the Audience—Line and Sinker

April 12, 2026by Richard Young

Reviewed by Jo-Anne Bishop

(Pictured: Jackson Balint as Richard Dreyfuss, Andrew Dodd as Roy Scheider, and Josh Cottrell as Robert Shaw. )

You don’t need a massive stage, a mechanical shark, or a Hollywood budget to make something memorable. Theatre Aezir proves that with The Shark is Broken, a smart, funny, and well-acted production now playing in the lower-level theatre at First Baptist Church in London, Ontario.

Written by Ian Shaw and Joseph Nixon, the play takes us behind the scenes of the famously troubled 1974 shoot of the Steven Spielberg film, Jaws. The setting: the Orca, floating off Martha’s Vineyard, where filming delays have left actors Robert Shaw, Richard Dreyfuss, and Roy Scheider stuck together with too much time on their hands and nowhere to go. As it turns out, that’s a perfect recipe for conflict, comedy, and the occasional moment of honesty.

The set does exactly what it should: half a boat, fully believable. It lets the audience look directly into the action and never tries to be more complicated than necessary. The props are right; the details are right—it all works. Add in clean, effective lighting and sound to move us through time, and the technical side of the show stays solid without ever stealing focus.

(Pictured: The Orca)

Director Dylan Christopher Trahan keeps things tight and lets the script and actors do the heavy lifting. The show takes a little time to find its groove—call it getting its sea legs—but once it does, it cruises along nicely.

But make no mistake, this is an actor’s show.

(Pictured: Jackson Balint as Richard Dreyfuss.)

Jackson R.R. Balint leans fully into Richard Dreyfuss’ jittery, fast-talking energy, bringing just the right amount of edge without tipping into parody. Andrew Dodd’s Roy Scheider is the calm in the storm—measured, grounded, and quietly confident, with a physical resemblance that doesn’t hurt either.

(Pictured: Andrew Dodd as Roy Scheider.)

But the real catch of the day is Josh Cottrell as Robert Shaw.

From the moment he steps on stage, you’re hooked—line, sinker, and probably the whole tackle box. This isn’t just a good performance; it’s a fully lived-in portrayal. The voice, the stance, the presence, it’s all there. At times, it genuinely feels like Robert Shaw himself wandered in, decided to do a few scenes, and left the rest of the cast to keep up. It’s a commanding performance and the anchor that holds everything together.

(Pictured: Josh Cottrell as Robert Shaw.)

What’s especially impressive is that none of the actors fall into simple impressions. These feel like real people, not SNL sketches. Their chemistry is strong, their timing is sharp, and their relationships keep the audience invested throughout.

Costumes by Elizabeth Durand are another win. Accurate to the film and era without feeling like costume for costume’s sake. It’s one more detail that helps sell the world of the play.

Full disclosure: I’m a longtime Jaws fan and a big admirer of Steven Spielberg, so this show was always going to be in my wheelhouse. But even if you’ve never seen the film (though honestly, you should fix that), there’s plenty here to enjoy. At its core, this is a story about big personalities stuck in a small space, and that’s something anyone can relate to.

It starts a bit slow, but once it hooks you, it doesn’t let go. By the end, I was all in, and possibly the first on my feet for a standing ovation.

Theatre Aezir’s The Shark is Broken is funny, engaging, and impressively well done. No frills, no fuss, just strong performances and a story that lands. And this small show proves – you don’t need a bigger theatre.

IF YOU GO:

What: Theatre Aezir’s presentation of The Shark is Broken, by Ian Shaw & Joseph Nixon

Where: First Baptist Church, 568 Richmond St, London, Ontario

When: April 9-19^th, 2026

Tickets: $38 Tickets for The Shark is Broken

Reviewed by Jo-Anne Bishop.

Background and Experience in the Arts

My background in the Arts started with an early love for music and dance. I attended my first concert at 10 years old (Helix at the Sarnia Arena in 1983!) and began tap and modern jazz dance lessons around the same time. My love for live theatre was built through school trips to the Stratford Festival to see plays like Romeo and Juliet, The Merchant of Venice, and Macbeth, and a trip to Toronto for The Phantom of the Opera, which quickly became my all-time favourite.

I dreamed of performing for many years, but being too self-conscious to audition in high school, I sat on the sidelines and instead reviewed music and theatre for our school newspaper. In 2013, I finally pushed my fears aside and was cast in my first play, Laughter on the 23^rd Floor, as Carol Wyman, the only female writer on the Max Prince show. I have since performed in productions of Birth (Jillian, 2016), Hamish (Annette, 2023) and The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime (Mrs. Alexander, 2024).

Previous Reviewing Activities

SCITS, Sarnia, Ontario – High school newspaper reviewer for Music and the Arts

London Fringe Festival, London, Ontario, 2012-2015

Independent Reviewer and Blogger (Theatre in London and The Pollyanna Papers), 2015-2016?

Why am I jumping back into the fray now?

After performing for a few years, I’ve decided to take a break from the grind of auditioning, rehearsing and performing. While I love it immensely, it’s a lot of work. Performing has given me a whole new perspective and appreciation of what goes into a production and the ability to look at reviewing with a fresh set of eyes.

Thoughts about the London arts and culture scene, especially local theatre

Hoo wee! London has such a wealth of talent, from youth to adults. Every time I see a play, I am amazed at how talented our actors, directors, producers, set/prop/costume/light/sound designers are. I don’t think causal observers realize just how much goes into making a production from the audition to the curtain call. It is a huge undertaking, and to think our theatres produce such world-class productions on some very tight budgets is astounding, especially at the community theatre level, where volunteers do everything.

Sadly, since COVID, I have witnessed a huge decline in attendance at performances, and it breaks my heart. I have also noticed a sad lack of reviews lately, which I find are necessary to give people an idea of what to expect and a reason to go to the theatre.

So, before I can put my feet on the stage again, I want to help put bodies in the seats. We need to reignite a love for theatre and the arts in this city.